Who said that против Who told you that

Когда что использовать в английском, со значением, регистром и примерами.

Who said that

Топ 3000 (частое)

Who told you that

Топ 1000 (очень частое)
Самое частое: Who told you that
 Who said thatWho told you that
Произношение🇬🇧 //huː sɛd ðæt//🇺🇸 //hu sɛd ðæt//🇬🇧 //huː təʊld jʊ ðæt//🇺🇸 //hu toʊld ju ðæt//
ЗначениеВопрос о том, кто сделал заявление.A question asking who made a statement.A question asking who gave you certain information.
ПримерI love that quote, but who said that?I can't believe you heard that! Who told you that?
РегистрНейтральноеНейтральное
Насколько частоеТоп 3000 (частое)Топ 1000 (очень частое)
Сочетанияwho said that quote, who said that line, who said that earlierWho told you that rumor, Who told you that story, Who told you that secret
Частые ошибкиIncorrectly using it as a statement, not a question., Forgetting to include 'that' when asking., Using it in formal contexts where direct attribution is required.Using incorrect word order, e.g., 'Who you told that?', Forgetting to add a question mark at the end., Misusing it in contexts where a simpler question, like 'Who said that?' would be appropriate.
Заметки по употреблениюИспользуется в разговорах, чтобы узнать, кто сказал цитату или сделал заявление. Это неформально и подходит для общения.Use in conversations to inquire about the speaker of a quote or statement. It's informal and suitable for chatting.Use this phrase in contexts where you're surprised or questioning the validity of information. It's neutral but can sound accusatory, so consider your tone.

Посмотри в реальных клипах

Who said that
Who told you that

Частые вопросы: Who said that против Who told you that

В чём разница между Who said that и Who told you that?

Who said that: A question asking who made a statement. Who told you that: A question asking who gave you certain information.

Что чаще встречается: Who said that и Who told you that?

Среди них Who told you that самое частое в повседневном английском.

Можно показать пример каждого?

Who said that: I love that quote, but who said that? Who told you that: I can't believe you heard that! Who told you that?

Можно ли использовать Who said that и Who told you that взаимозаменяемо?

Не всегда. Who said that и Who told you that близки и иногда пересекаются, но различаются по регистру, частоте и употреблению, поэтому замена одного другим может изменить смысл или тон. Стоит свериться с различиями выше, прежде чем заменять.